Showing posts with label Faustin Kabwe. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Faustin Kabwe. Show all posts

Friday, August 07, 2009

Malila defends Sakala and Chitengi re-appointment

Attorney General Mumba Malila on August 6 asked Ndola High Court Judge Munalula Lisimba to dismiss the petition against Chief Justice Ernest Sakala and Justice Peter Chitengi because their re-appointments did not need the ratification of the National Assembly because that was only applicable to new appointments.

This is in a case in which former Access Financial Services (AFS) directors, Aaron Chungu and Faustin Kabwe, through their lawyers John Sangwa and Associates, petitioned the High Court to remove the two from performing Supreme Court duties due to alleged over-age. The attorney general made the submissions yesterday before Mr Justice Lisimba when the matter came up for hearing.

This was in response to the petition that Mr Justice Sakala and Mr Justice Chitengi were above 65 years and were re-appointed by the republican president to continue serving as judges for a period not exceeding seven years in respect of each of them.

“The respondents accordingly deny most emphatically that Article 1 and Article 93 of the Constitution are violated by the non-ratification of the re-appointments of Mr Justice Sakala and Mr Justice Chitengi,” he said.

Malila further denied the allegation that Kabwe and Chungu’s right to a fair hearing before an independent and impartial court established by law was violated claiming that the court that heard their appeal of July 9 this year was not an established court by law.

“At all material times, the Supreme Court panels and high court benches in the judicature were legally constituted in accordance with the Constitution and other relevant laws,” he said.

He said all judges serve on terms and conditions clearly set out in the law and that the petitioners were not entitled to any of the relief they were seeking. Malila said the orders prayed for by the petitioners that Mr Justice Sakala and Mr Justice Chitengi should vacate their offices would be an attempt to suspend Supreme Court judges outside the provisions of the Constitution.

“The order that Mr Justice Sakala and justice Chitengi must vacate office will be contrary to the provisions for the removal of a judge as set out in the Constitution, which require setting up of a tribunal when the question of removal of a judge arises,” he said.

Malila said Kabwe and Chungu’s action to seek the removal of Mr Justice Sakala and Mr Justice Chitengi was not only unprecedented but was designed to cause a Constitutional crisis, and was contrary to every conceivable way to public interest.

Deputy chief State advocate, Joe Simachela said the allegations against Mr Justice Sakala and Mr Justice Chitengi were false and malicious.

Monday, June 22, 2009

Convict Chiluba and his co-accused over US$500,000

The court should convict Second Republican president, Frederick Chiluba and his two co-accused persons, former directors of Access Financial Services (AFS), Faustin Kabwe and Aaron Chungu on all the 12 counts they are each charged with, the state submitted June 19. The State says the evidence before the court has proved beyond any reasonable doubt that the accused persons committed the offences under each count in respect of which they are charged.

This is in the case in which Chiluba, Chungu and Kabwe are charged with theft of public funds amounting to over US$500, 000.

The State submitted that the monies were paid out in favour of beneficiaries other than the Government, or deposited in private accounts a conversion, which coincided with an intention to permanently deprive the Government from use or enjoyment of the funds. The State also submitted that according to the meaning of section 21 of the Penal Code all parties to a common unlawful purpose are liable as principal offenders irrespective of the role played in the joint enterprise.

Further the State has proposed that the court deals with these counts together especially that the evidence relating to these counts is largely identical.

“ This honourable court, may thus if the evidence before it warrants, convict the three accused persons either in counts one to three or counts four to six as principal offenders, even though they were not all perpetrators of the crime,” reads the submissions.

Task Force prosecutor Mutembo Nchito submitted that in the above counts, Kabwe and Chungu were the principal offenders while Chiluba was an accessory before the fact as he procured the commissioned offences charged in the said counts according to section 21 (2) of the Penal Code. He submitted that in counts seven, eight and nine actus reas in these counts occurred through the fraudulent conversion of Government funds to the Zamtrop account for the use of Chiluba’s children.

Nchito further submitted that Chiluba was liable to be convicted as a principal offender either on the basis of the principal of joint unlawful purpose with person here not indicated or for procuring the offence in counts seven to nine.

“The evidence before this court is that, that was a Government account and that all the monies in it ought to be treated as such, we wish to stress that the payments to Chiluba’s children were made out of the Zamtrop account, the defence ought to show that monies paid to his children were private sources,” read the submissions.

And in counts 10 through to 12, the State submitted that the transactions involved in these counts were similar to those involving counts one to six in that each transaction was a perfect replica of the others. He submitted that at the time the conversion of the funds took place the accused persons intended indefinitely to exclude the Government from enjoying its rights to the monies alleged to have been stolen.

“The fact that Kabwe and Chungu did not want to keep a ledger at AFS to replicate the ledger at Meer Care and Desai, the State submit that the action of the two indicated that they did not want these transactions to ever come to light since stolen Government funds were laundered through this account,” he stated.

The State submitted that the circumstances in the case revealed a joint unlawful purpose between Chiluba and his co accused persons as there was clear intention to divert Government funds to procure properties for Vincent Malambo and Eric Silwamba by Chiluba as promises although he might not be directly involved in actus reas.

Earlier, Chiluba submitted that the case be dismissed because it appears to be novel and a mere fiction. Chiluba said this in his final defence submissions filed in court by his lawyers, Robert Simeza and John Sangwa. Judgment has been set for July 20.